Best Pack-n-Play Mattress Picks 2023

The best Pack n Play mattresses are made for comfort, durability and easy cleaning. They fit neatly into standard Pack n Play portable cribs, and can be taken on the go. Some are machine washable, while others are waterproof and offer the convenience of an easy wipe-down.

What to look for in the best Pack-n-Play mattress

Some of the best baby registries have solid Pack-n-Play options, but there are a few key details to look out for when choosing a separate mattress.

• Size: Though most Pack n Play mattress options are made for standard play yards, it's important to pay close attention to measurements. If there's any type of gap, the play yard isn't safe, and safety is the most important feature.
• Material: Look for breathable, non-flammable material so your child stays cool and comfortable for the best night of sleep.
• Washability: Kids are messy. The best pack-and-play mattresses need to be more than "spot-cleaned." Look for something with a removable, machine-washable cover.
• Portability: Mattresses that fold end/or include a carrying bag make life a lot easier.
• Comfort: The biggest takeaway (aside from safety) is comfort. You want your child to enjoy being in the play yard — otherwise it won't last. This is the same major factor that determines best crib mattress and the best toddler mattress. It's important for portable beds, too.

The best Pack-n-Play mattress picks 2023

• Best overall: hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad
• Best budget: Dream On Me Square Corner Playmat
• Best Graco: Pack and Play Mattress Topper
• Best organic: 100% Cotton Pack and Play Mattress
• Best washable: Hygee Hush Washable Pack and Play Mattress
• Best Walmart: Bi-comfer Memory Foam Mattress

Best Overall

hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad

With nearly 33,000 reviews on Amazon, the hiccapop pack and play mattress pad gets the best overall for a number of reasons. Not only is the one-inch thick design made for a snug fit (no gaps), but the comfort level is beyond measure.

Comfortable enough for play or sleep, this mattress is portable, machine washable, thanks to a zipper for easy removal, and an ultra-soft, hypoallergenic jacquard cover. Rounded corners and superior edge support create a snug fit for the safest sleep environment. We love how easy to clean it is, and the lightweight design makes it a cinch to travel with and store.

Pros

• Soft to the touch, though supportive for growing spines
• No gaps, per federal safety regulations, for ultimate safety
• Machine washable
• Memory foam provides excellent spinal support
• Super soft and comfortable
• Hypoallergenic

Cons

• Only fits play yards sized 38"x 26"

Dream On Me 3” Square Corner Playmat

For parents on a budget, the Dream On Me three-inch Playmat provides comfort and quality at a great rate. Made from durable vinyl and supportive foam, the Greenguard Gold & JPMA-certified pack-and-play mattress complies with the Federal Flammability Standard.

More than 10,900 reviewers love the waterproof cover that repels liquid. This affordable play yard mattress cleans up in a jiffy with mild soap and water on its durable, high-quality vinyl cover. Plus, it's a total steal at under $40.

Pros

• Budget-friendly under-$40 pricing
• Fits Graco pack-and-play models and several other standard-sized play yards
• Waterproof
• Greenguard GOLD certified
• Cleans easily

Cons

• Some reviewers say it's loud when baby moves

Pack and Play Mattress Topper

Graco is a long-trusted source for baby products, so if you're in the market for one of the best pack-and-play mattresses made by the company, this is the one. With an average 4.7 rating on Amazon, the baby-grade skin-friendly fabric is unmatched and fits any standard Graco Pack-n-Play perfectly.

This mattress has loads of support through high-density sponge foam and anti-slip material. The brand also makes our favorite convertible car seat and one of the best baby cribs of all time, so it's one-stop shopping for new parents.

Pros

• Dimensional edges to keep toys from falling through the cracks
• Fits all major pack and plays
• Anti-interference performance (aka quiet!)

Cons

• A mild odor can linger for a day or two after unpackaging, but it quickly fades

100% Cotton Pack and Play Mattress

For environmentally-conscious parents, this pack-and-play mattress features a 100% organic cotton cover. The sustainable waffle knitting absorbs moisture and keeps baby safe and warm—even on a portable crib mattress.

It's accented by 3-D mesh that is breathable and well-ventilated, which is great for hot days, too. An environmentally degradable foam provides enough support to keep baby's spine aligned. Reinforced edges are made with safety in mind. It's a steal, and rivals some of our favorite toddler mattresses on the market.

Pros

• 100% organic cotton cover and sustainable foam inners
• Breathable materials
• Durable yet comfortable
• Reinforced edges
• Easy to clean

Cons

• Only fits play yards measured 39.5" x 28.5"

Hygee Hush Washable Pack and Play Mattress

The Hygge Hush pack-and-play mattress, made from polyester, is a bestseller with its three-inch height thickness and high-density foam. It's a firm mattress that offers spine and neck support growing bodies need. Plus, it's one of the best options on the market for babies who end up regularly sleeping in portable cribs.

The ultra-soft jacquard cover is waterproof, leak-free, and hypoallergenic. Parents rave about the removable cover that quickly and easily unzips to toss it in the washing machine, too! It's durable enough to stand up to any of your best laundry detergents.

Pros

• Simple unzipping to remove the cover and toss in the wash
• CertiPUR-US Certificated memory foam
• Nontoxic
• Hypoallergenic
• Waterproof

Cons

• May not fit totally flush against play yard edges in knock-off Graco play yards

Bi-Comfer Foam Mattress

Whatever your budget, one of the best pack-and-play mattresses an be found in your local Walmart. The memory foam meets all U.S. safety regulations with a firm side for babies up to nine months, and a softer side for toddlers nine months and up.

Removable, machine washable and easily portable by folding into thirds, this one hits all the right notes at affordable Walmart pricing. Parents rave about the quality and comfort. It's water resistant so you don't have to worry about a pee leak or faulty diaper.

Pros

• Affordable Walmart pricing for a premium product
• Machine washable
• Two sides (firm or soft) to ensure your child is comfortable from baby all the way through a younger kids' mattress stage
• Meets safety regulations

Cons

• Some reviewers stated the mattress was thinner than they thought it would be